The Promise by David Galgut promises a lot to the reader. Critically acclaimed, man booker prized winning and very ambitious in scope. It’s a family drama set against the back drop of South Africa’s churning history over decades.
The family in question is the Swartz’s. If the idea of a family gathering is triggering to you, the Swartz’s will be familiar territory. They live on a large wealthy farm that dates back to white settlement and enjoy a privilege and double standard allowed by almost invisible black servants that’s mostly taken for granted. At the same time they quietly live in fear of losing it to the masses. The story unfolds over a series of funerals which is how the novel tracks time with the authors use of multiple perspectives and indirect discourse technique.
The first funeral reveals the promise in question, a dying wish that their black maid is granted the small house she lives in on the property. The breaking of this promise reflects the journey of racial injustice and unfulfilled promises in post-apartheid South Africa.
Ultimately “The Promise" is a divisive read. Either you you find these characters interesting for their flaws and engage in the irregular structure, or you don’t care because of who they are and hence the ambitious narrative falls flat, failing to shine light on the important backdrop of South Africa’s troubled journey despite the moments of good writing.
For me, I was left wanting for a cut to the chase real historical account. For you, it may be a compelling look into a world of relationships, race, power politics and redemption.
Aaron Elsey (Geelong Chapter)